Little Bill Clinton

A school year in the life of a new American

Daily blog

Charter schools a vice?

By Mary Wiltenburg | February 26, 2009 edition

Obama may love charter schools, Georgia may be on the fence, but St. Louis school leaders see charter schools as a vice. While researching our upcoming story about the International Community School and charter school facilities, I learned that last year, as the leaders of St. Louis public schools prepared to sell a bunch of empty school buildings, the district barred certain unwanted buyers: “liquor stores, landfills, distilleries, as well as shops that sell “so-called ‘sexual toys,’ ” writes St. Louis Post-Dispatch reporter David Hunn. “They also blackballed charter schools.”

This despite the city’s 17 public charter schools and 9,500 charter students – and eight new charters expected to open by fall 2010 – writes Bill Schulz of the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools. “Porn shops and liquor stores and charter schools, oh my!” he quipped.

Huhn reports: ” ‘We tried to buy three,’ said Susan Uchitelle, board member at Confluence Academy, a charter school with three campuses and 2,700 students in St. Louis. ‘We finally just gave up…. It was made very clear they weren’t going to sell to us. They’d show them to us. They’d let us walk through them. But then they’d take them off the market.’ ”

Now, as the school board debates closing 29 more schools, politicians, lobby groups, and residents of the neighborhoods surrounding the buildings are up in arms at the thought that charter schools can’t move in to replace the once-great schools that anchored whole neighborhoods.

The Missouri Charter Public Schools Association, State Representative T.D. El-Amin, and many others are now working to reverse the ban. The Children’s Education Alliance of Missouri’s YouTube video makes their case. One resident they interview puts it succinctly: “That’s crazy.”

Comments

1. JahLove63 | 02.26.09

Now I understand why my Dad (a native of Missouri) calls it Misery!
St. Louis school leaders are once again saving their own arses and not looking out for the better of the society as a whole. I would like to see ALL public schools become charter schools. My son attends one in California that is more sustainable than the public schools it is surrounded by. Although, I’m sure many families might find the required 50 volunteer hours per family per academic year a bit cumbersome. Anything to ensure education for our future generation!

2. fiendish avatar | 02.26.09

Charter schools are great, in general, because the parents actively participate in them. Forcing charter schools on people who have no interest in their kids’ education won’t help unless those parents take an active role in the schools–which would save public schools in the first place.

3. Hazel Kirk, St. Louis | 02.27.09

I do think it is crazy for the public schools to prohibit the charter schools from taking their school buildings. Are they thinking that the charter schools are driving them out of business?

4. JenniferO | 02.27.09

Sadly, it’s not just St. Louis but it’s also happening to this very school. I have a closed Dekalb County elementary school at the end of my street. ICS and my neighborhood lobbied hard to convince the Dekalb County School board to allow them to rent the facility. The board refused and now this school sits empty.

5. Joy | 02.27.09

Wow, I am so thankful for the option of a charter school. After staying at home with our children until it was time for kindergarten, I wanted to choose a school that wouldn’t undo all our hard work.

6. Candace | 03.03.09

I am a volunteer tutor in an inner-city St. Louis public school, which is one of the batch slated for closing this year. The neighborhood is devastated! It would be wonderful to have a charter school take its place in this fully functional, air-conditioned building.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Leave a Comment

  By clicking "Submit Comment", you agree to our Terms of Service.

We do not publish all comments, and we do not publish comments immediately. The comments feature is a forum to discuss the ideas in our stories. Constructive debate - even pointed disagreement - is welcome, but personal attacks on other commenters are not, and will not be published.

Tip: Do not write a novel. Keep it short. We will not publish lengthy comments. Come up with your own statements. This is not a place to cut and paste an email you received. If we recognize it as such, we won't post it.

Please do not post any comments that are commercial in nature or that violate copyrights.

Finally, we will not publish any comments that we regard as obscene, defamatory, or intended to incite violence.